Archive for the ‘Energy-related Administrative Law’ Category

Electric Rate Shock: Ontario Energy Board

Sunday, February 7th, 2010

The attached essay is the first of a series on the factors underlying the dramatic increase in power rates about to arrive on bills of Ontario electricity consumers.

Access PDF: electric-rate-shock-oeb.

Separating Electricity and Gas Regulation in Ontario

Monday, July 13th, 2009

Establishing and sustaining an appropriate relationship between a regulatory agency and the respective governments it serves is the foundation stone for effective regulatory functioning. This relationship is guided by the regulatory mandate, key elements of which are the arrangements for the tenure of the decision makers. This essay addresses these issues in the context of the regulatory governance of Ontario’s energy sector and argues for the separation of natural gas and electricity regulation.

PDF link:

separating-ontario-gas-and-electricity-regulation

Removal of Keen from CNSC: Commentary on Federal Court decision

Monday, July 13th, 2009

The federal government’s recently reaffirmed right to terminate without cause the head of a technical safety-oriented regulatory agency, illustrates a fundamental barrier to the independence of quasi judicial regulatory bodies where the key decision makers hold tenure at the pleasure of the government of the day.

PDF link:

notes-on-federal-court-decision-against-keen

Home Invasion David Suzuki Style

Tuesday, June 23rd, 2009

The bill to create the Ontario Green Energy Act, when first introduced, would have empowered government agents to enter private homes to investigate energy and water usage. Many prominent environmental organizations endorsed the Act while it included raid provisions.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U4oh0Etg3m0

Green Energy Act Paradox

Tuesday, June 16th, 2009

The Ontario Green Energy Act, passed in May 2009, is extremely popular with the public notwithstanding both its infringements on basic individual and democratic rights, and also the substantially higher electricity rates it will cause. This post suggests that close coordination between government, renewable energy businesses, and environmental organizations, particularly government funding of environmental groups, helps to explain the political success of the legislation. This video was part of a panel presentation by Tom Adams at a York University Osgoode Hall Law School Professional Development conference June 15, 2009.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KT62LNcbJBI

Ontario’s green energy plan: Interference goes green

Wednesday, May 20th, 2009

In this article, originally published March 5, 2009  reprinted here courtesy of the National Post, Tom Adams argues that Ontario’s proposed Green Energy Act will undermine the basic foundations for effective public utility regulation in Ontario’s electricity sector. The article includes one of the first public comments during debate over the proposed legislation expressing concern about the extraordinary search and seizure provisions of the Green Energy Act as originally proposed and the threat this provision presented to civil liberties. This section was later removed by the Ontario government prior to passage of the legislation.

PDF link: ontarios-green-energy-plan_interference-goes-green-march-5-2009

Transcript of testimony on Green Energy Act (Bill 150)

Wednesday, May 20th, 2009

The Green Energy Act (GEA) will transform Ontario’s electricity future. The attached link provides an analysis of the GEA as presented on April 6, 2009 to the Ontario legislative committee considering the bill.

PDF link: transcript-of-appearance-re-bill-150-green-energy-act

Transforming Ontario’s Electricity Paradigm: Lessons Arising from Wind Power Integration

Wednesday, May 20th, 2009

In the following keynote address to Professional Engineers of Ontario, Annual General Meeting, May 9, 2009, Tom Adams outlines the challenges ahead for integrating renewable energy into the Ontario power grid. Data is presented showing how wind power production and electricity usage are out of sync, how winter wind power output is concentrated on the warmer winter days when load tends to be low, how distance between wind farms provides limited smoothing benefit, why it is inaccurate to claim that the wind is “always blowing somewhere”, and how wind output from distant farms can be strongly correlated even sometimes when measured on a 5 minute time scale. Knowledge gaps on wind integration current as of the date of presentation are identified.

PDF link: keynote-for-peo-may-2009-transforming-ontario_s-power-system